Back to Journal
Policy & Planning

Town, Regional District, Town Again: The Patchwork Behind 721 Lazo

By Jeff Nield

I drive Lazo Road all the time. Head out of downtown Comox on Comox Avenue as it turns into Pritchard, take a right on Balmoral, a left on Torrence and a quick right onto Lazo, and you’ve left the Town of Comox for Electoral Area B of the Comox Valley Regional District (CVRD). At Butchers Road the town comes back on your left while the right stays in the regional district, and it stays that way after you turn left to stay on Lazo. Shortly past Guthrie, the regional district closes in on both sides, until you reach 721 Lazo Road and the town reappears on your right. Through Point Holmes you’re in Comox on both sides.

Confused? I don’t blame you. That’s the head-scratcher of the Comox Peninsula.

Parts of the town out here, Point Holmes among them, are as rural as anything in the regional district, and in places it’s the regional district that sits between them and the rest of Comox. That’s no accident of geography. Point Holmes came into the town in the mid-2000s, when a majority of owners in the proposed area petitioned to join to get piped water. The town would only supply its water to properties within its boundaries, so annexation was the price of the pipe. 721 Lazo Road shows how that history can play out for the people who live along the line.

The same week Comox council voted to start downzoning 1890 Comox Avenue, a reader sent me a note about another rezoning. She lives on Andrew Avenue, a short dead-end street on the regional district side of the line, and her street is where the owners of 721 Lazo want to connect the private road into their proposed six-lot subdivision. Her email followed with the owners’ letter to council, her neighbourhood’s rebuttal, two survey plans, and pages of photographs of Andrew Avenue and the property’s existing driveway off of Lazo, each annotated with pavement widths and the gaps between the trees. She closed by asking whether I could see a better solution.

I don’t have one to hand her. But the further I got into the letters and reports, the less it looked like a fight about one property and the more it reflected a region-wide issue of jurisdiction. The town decides, the people on Andrew Avenue can’t vote for the council making the call, and because the rezoning fits the town’s plan, provincial law ruled out a public hearing.

Where the lines meet

721 Lazo Road is a 5.64-acre parcel at Point Holmes, inside the Town of Comox, running from Lazo Road down to the Strait of Georgia. The owners want to rezone it for six bare land strata lots at the waterfront end, and in exchange the forested upper portion, about 1.3 hectares, would become a town nature park. Council gave the bylaw third reading on August 5, with an amendment from Councillor Jenn Meilleur requiring an independent environmental review and development permit approval before adoption, along with interim tree protection, public waterfront access and a pedestrian right of way through the private strata road. The bylaw hasn’t been adopted yet.

Not everyone signed on. Alison Mewett and William Marsh, a landscape architect and a retired university professor who have lived across the road at 766 Lazo for 25 years, told council in a May letter that owners came door to door asking neighbours to join the request to move into Comox. The reason they gave was failing wells, along with an assurance that it had nothing to do with density. Mewett and Marsh declined, and their side of Lazo is still regional district. They say the town promised a local area plan for the new area that was never done, and that once taxes went up, requests to subdivide followed. That’s their account. The town’s 2005 newsletter confirms the petition and the water, though it says nothing about density or an area plan. Two decades later, here we are with a rezoning and, if they’re right, still no area plan.

The new lots wouldn’t use the existing driveway off Lazo. The owners propose a private strata road off Andrew Avenue, which currently dead-ends at the property’s southern edge, and that is where the jurisdictions overlap. The Town of Comox decides the zoning. The people who live on Andrew Avenue vote for one CVRD director, who has no vote on a Comox rezoning, and they can’t vote for Comox council at all. Then-director Richard Hardy did what that seat allows. After meeting with more than 30 constituents in March, and walking the site with Mayor Minions, he wrote to the transportation minister and the mayor in April asking that access come from the existing driveway or Hutton Road instead. The letter went into council’s package. It carried no vote.

The regional district did get a say, through the town’s referral, and how that say reached council shows the problem as well as anything. The CVRD’s April letter, from its manager of long range planning, said that from a regional perspective a through road joining Andrew Avenue and Hutton Road would be the preferred outcome. If that wasn’t feasible, it suggested avoiding a permanent cul-de-sac and considering access from an existing Town road, rather than a strata road that would be hard to extend or convert later. It also raised questions about the bare land strata form, the reliance on septic and the building envelopes. The executive summary of the staff report that went to council on May 20 reduced all of that to one line: “the CVRD staff analysis supports an extension of Andrew Avenue.” The body of the report described the letter more fully, but on the day council took up the report, the same planning manager told residents in writing that the summary line didn’t accurately reflect the CVRD’s comments, and that the regional district doesn’t take positions on applications in other jurisdictions. The CVRD’s formal referral response, the regional district’s one official say in the decision, reached council in a summary its author says got it wrong.

The record on the road itself is mixed. The transportation ministry told the town it had no objection to the rezoning, on conditions that include a formal access permit before construction. The owners’ June letter described that as provincial approval, and the neighbours point out that no permit has been issued. Staff concluded Andrew was the best of the three routes: a road to Hutton would mean cutting through a large sand dune near an eagle tree and a stand of Garry oaks, and using the existing driveway off Lazo would run vehicles through the planned park and its pathway, and would need widening for emergency access. A follow-up email from the CVRD’s planning manager to residents, which they shared with me, says the regional district did no technical review of its own, and that questions about upgrades to Andrew Avenue, who pays for them and liability are for the Town of Comox to answer.

Mayor Nicole Minions seemed to feel the tension. Explaining her vote to the Comox Valley Record, she described asking herself, “If it was all the Town of Comox or all of CVRD and that boundary line wasn’t there, what would my viewpoint on the development be?”

What the street was laid out for

There’s an older layer of planning under all of this. On one of the neighbours’ own alternative plans, Andrew Avenue is marked as a 20-metre right-of-way, about 66 feet, with five metres of pavement running down it. I can’t say whether whoever drew the original subdivision expected the road to carry on someday. The regional plan has a view, though. The CVRD’s letter notes that the Area B land next to 721 Lazo is designated a Settlement Expansion Area, meant to join a municipality eventually, with public water and sewer. That’s why its planners would rather see a through road than a dead end.

The street grew into something else: a quiet dead end, with homes on septic and wells. That leaves me with questions nobody in the record has answered. How much of that 20-metre allowance is still open, and how much has settled into lawns, hedges and fences over the decades? Five metres of pavement says a lot about how the street is used and very little about how much room the road was given. Andrew Avenue ends at a chain-link fence and there’s no turnaround. Backing a fire engine down a narrow dead end is slow, awkward work when minutes count. The proposed layout shows a turnaround at the end of the new strata road, so a fire crew could come in, work and get back out without reversing the length of the street. Whether that would make Andrew Avenue safer as well as busier is a question for the fire department, and it belongs in the comparison too.

Streets settle into the shape their residents give them, and a quiet dead end is a good place to live. But the infrastructure under it was built for a rural street, while the regional plan expects something larger. Somebody eventually has to decide whether a street keeps the shape its residents built around it or grows into the one the surveyors drew, and here the people who live on it aren’t the ones deciding.

Where each side stands

The owners’ case, and the town’s, is that this is the best deal available. By the owners’ account the family has held the land for more than 90 years and worked toward a subdivision for about eight. They describe six lots, two more than allowed when they started, in exchange for a park in the family’s name and more than $40,000 a year in added tax revenue, and they warned that if council balked they would do a standard subdivision and “clear the land as permitted.” Town staff argued that a rezoning lets Comox require protection and negotiate a park, while a straight subdivision would give it neither. Chief Administrative Officer Jordan Wall told CHLY the neighbours’ alternatives “would result in more tree removal.”

The Radford Beach neighbourhood group, which says it speaks for more than 70 neighbours, says it isn’t opposed to the owners subdividing. Its July 6 rebuttal argues that the town’s own Official Community Plan (OCP) treats Point Holmes as unsuited to added density and calls for subdivision here to have road access to Lazo, and that the technical reports don’t compare the access routes in any detail. They point out that the watermain the town wants along the existing driveway already clears that corridor, and ask why a second road should go through the sand bluff at the end of Andrew. A neighbour who builds homes drew alternative layouts using the driveway, with a wildlife corridor along the southern boundary.

I do wonder how much of this comes down to traffic. Hardy wrote that the route through the end of their street was the neighbours’ primary concern, and a new road past your front door is a perfectly human thing to resist. The neighbours who have pushed hardest say their main concern is the dune, the foreshore and a wildlife corridor from Lazo Marsh to the shore, and I take them at their word. If the town is right that their layouts would cost more Garry oaks, those two concerns may not point the same way.

The “worst case” has also shifted. A new Subdivision and Development Servicing Bylaw, which council adopted at a special meeting on August 7, prohibits subdividing land on septic without a sewer connection, with one exception: 721 Lazo Road, on condition of “a minimum 1.3ha parkland dedication.” Under that wording, a subdivision of the property using that exception would also have to give up at least 1.3 hectares of parkland, which takes some of the force out of the argument that council had to choose between this plan and a cleared site.

I’m not a biologist, and I won’t guess whether the bluff or the trees along the driveway should give way. People who know more than I do have weighed in, though. The Comox Valley Conservation Partnership, which didn’t oppose the rezoning, asked council in July for more information before deciding: a proper inventory of the big Douglas firs and the Garry oaks, including those near the water line from Lazo Road, and a better understanding of what regrading the dune would do to the sand moving along the shore and to the forage fish that spawn on the beach in front. Mewett and Marsh, who have studied this shoreline for years, warned that the retaining wall in front of the property failed in 2011 and that the next failure could put septic fields at risk and bring calls to extend sewer. Councillor Meilleur’s amendment requiring an independent environmental review is the town’s answer to some of that.

That sand doesn’t stop at the town line either. Both letters say this stretch of shoreline feeds Goose Spit, a park the regional district runs. Who gets a say in the decision is a separate question, and it’s the one this post is about.

The one door that closed

For a rezoning like this, a public hearing used to be the default. For years, B.C. councils could waive a hearing when a rezoning was consistent with the OCP, and a 2021 change made skipping one easier still. The province’s own guidancesays that when a hearing is held, all persons who believe their interest in property is affected must be given a reasonable opportunity to be heard. That right doesn’t depend on which side of a municipal boundary you live on. For a household on the regional district side, a hearing was the one point in the process where the law guaranteed them a chance to speak.

Bill 44 turned the option into a rule. A local government now must not hold a public hearing on a residential rezoning that is consistent with its OCP, as long as housing makes up at least half of the proposed floor area. In May, Comox gave notice that a hearing was prohibited for this bylaw. The staff report quotes the relevant OCP policy, 19.6, in full. It says subdivision here “should require continuous paved road access along any parcel frontage and from each parcel to Lazo Road.” It also says protecting sensitive ecosystems may significantly affect minimum parcel size. Staff relied on that second part, and on the park dedication, to find the proposal consistent. What the report doesn’t explain is how access from Andrew Avenue squares with the first part. The neighbours say they asked and never got an answer. To its credit, the town notified the whole Radford Beach neighbourhood, which staff say it wasn’t legally required to do, and council held an information session in July. Neither carries the legal standing of a hearing.

Comox did refer this rezoning to the regional district, and the province requires towns to consider consulting their regional district whenever they write or amend an OCP. Both of those happen between governments. The referral on this rezoning went to regional district staff, whose priorities aren’t necessarily those of the people on the street. Take away the hearing and those residents are left with letters to a council they don’t elect, and freedom of information requests. The neighbours say the town itself pointed them toward a freedom of information request, and in May they filed one asking for the agency referral responses and the analysis behind the route ranking. The staff report summarized several referrals but attached only two letters, the CVRD’s and Hardy’s. They say the town has since extended its deadline to respond twice, most recently to March 2027. By then the bylaw could be adopted and the development permit well along, which means the documents they asked for may arrive after the decisions they wanted to understand have already been made.

It isn’t only Lazo

Area B wraps around much of Comox, so a lot of the town’s edge is somebody else’s front yard. That is where a good share of the town’s new housing is going.

On Aspen Road, Highstreet Ventures is building Aspen East: five four-storey buildings with 280 units and 26 townhomes. The Discourse reported in July that the residents most upset about it live on Acacia and Hector Roads and McQuinn Drive in Area B, just outside the town boundary, where construction closed an informal trail across private land that they’d used for years to reach Aspen Road. The developer is building a greenway trail from Hector Road to Aspen Road, and Hector Road is being extended with sidewalks. Even so, because they can’t vote in town elections, residents told the reporter they feel council disregards them. One said she had contacted the developer, the town, the CVRD and the ministry. “No one is listening and we are exhausted,” she said.

Arzeena Hamir made the same point in this fall’s campaign. Construction, she told My Comox Valley Now, is “going up right against Area B” instead of in the town centre, bringing traffic onto rural roads without sidewalks. She won the Area B seat back by 1,156 votes to 694.

What would help

Comox doesn’t need to throw out the 721 Lazo bylaw to deal with this. Before adoption, council can ask for a more detailed comparison than the table staff presented in July: each access route side by side, including the neighbours’ layouts, with tree counts, Garry oak and older forest disturbed, regrading of the bluff, and what Andrew Avenue itself would need in widening, drainage and tree removal to carry the new homes. If the regional district wants Andrew to connect through to Hutton one day, the people who live on it should hear that from the regional district directly, rather than in a referral letter attached to a town staff report. Nobody has told them what happens to their street, and I’m not sure anyone knows yet.

The town could also invite the new Area B director to speak to council about 721 Lazo. The two governments already share a table: Comox appoints members of its council to the CVRD board, where Hamir now sits. A boundary question like this one is exactly what that table is for.

And if the new provincial government follows through on its promise to repeal or amend Bill 44, I hope the rewrite deals with the edges. I wrote in August about where that fight over local control started, in Whose Call Is It? Removing hearings for projects that fit the plan is defensible. A simple fix would be to require a formal referral to the neighbouring regional district, and a hearing for affected residents, whenever a rezoning’s access or servicing runs through another jurisdiction. People affected by a decision should have some way to be heard by the government making it, whichever side of the line they live on.

The owners have waited eight years, and I understand why their patience is gone. A park is a fine thing to trade density for. Before council adopts the bylaw, it can still put the routes side by side. The people at the end of Andrew Avenue are being asked to pay part of the price, but since they don’t vote or pay taxes in the Town of Comox, they have almost no political voice in the decision.

Note: I use AI to help research, compile and structure these posts, then edit them substantially against the sources listed below.

Sources

Keep Reading

More Articles

Get in Touch

Have Questions About the Comox Valley?

Whether you're relocating, investing, or just exploring — I'm happy to share what I know about the local market.

Jeff Nield Real Estate

Downsizer Equity Calculator

Whether you're looking to unlock equity, reduce expenses, or trade complexity for ease - enter your numbers below to see the full picture.

Current Home
$
$
$
$
Desired New Home
$
$
$
$
$
Commissions, legal fees, inspection & other costs
$
BC: 1% on first $200K - 2% on balance - auto-calculated
Your Downsizing Snapshot
Estimated Financial Outcomes
Equity Unlocked
$0
Total Annual Savings
$0
Monthly Cash Freed Up
$0
Annual savings breakdown
Maintenance savings$0
Property tax savings$0
Strata fees (new home)$0
Total annual savings$0
Ready to explore your options?Complimentary, no-obligation market appraisal for Comox Valley homeowners.
Book Free Appraisal